Overview

Big Jay's Pizzeria, located at 9250 River Rd in Marcy, NY, offers a true taste of authentic pizza craftsmanship. As a dedicated pizza restaurant, Big Jay's focuses on delivering classic, hand-tossed pies made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The dough is perfectly balanced—crisp on the outside, yet soft and chewy within—providing a base that complements the rich tomato sauce and melty cheeses.

The welcoming atmosphere mirrors the warmth of their service. The space is casual and inviting, ideal for families, groups of friends, or anyone seeking a relaxed dining experience. Whether you’re stopping for a quick lunch or settling in for a cozy dinner, Big Jay’s environment feels both comfortable and unpretentious.

Big Jay’s target audience ranges from local residents craving hometown flavor to visitors passing through Marcy who appreciate authentic, flavorful pizza. Their ability to maintain a neighborhood pizzeria charm while offering consistently satisfying meals makes them stand out in the Central New York dining scene.

With easy access via River Road and a phone number ready for orders at +1 315-982-9536, getting a slice of Big Jay’s signature pizza is straightforward. For those who value a genuine pizza experience—melding quality ingredients with a cozy local spot—Big Jay's Pizzeria is worth a visit.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy

What Customers Say

Nicole Spencer
Mar 7,2026
4/5
The girl at the front counter is lovely, so sweet and such a kind smile. Great service. First time ordering even though I live and work next to it, but I will be back. My only issue was there was cheese on my salad even though I tried to take it off but only the blue cheese was removed. I’m lactose intolerant so this kinda sucked but I threw out the top layer and it was great! The girl at the front counter again was so lovely that even though either I messed up/they messed up I will be back. Lovely girl! Even asked if I needed a fork, got me a bag, etc.
Rob S.
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Stopped by for the Tuesday wing special. Added a few slices and grabbed some extra wings to go. The wings were perfect! We ordered xtra crispy and they were superb! Soooo saucy, so crisp but still tender inside, and soooo good! I got the ATOMIC and asked for as hot as they could make them. Here's the only soft spot in their wings: heat. While they were very tasty, and did put some tingling to my tongue and lips, overall it wasn't worth the extra buck. If you're looking for flavor with a fair amount of short-lived burn they're perfect for you. I just wanted a little more pain. They rest of the order was spot on perfection. We will be going back again even though there are places closer just because this was done just so right. Keep it up Big Jays!
William L
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Food is consistently delicious! We use them to cater all of our party's they deliver on time always hot and fresh! Riggies, Rolls, Pizza, Salads, and Calzones all the very best around by far a must try
Annette Conte
Mar 7,2026
5/5
so this was my first time ordering the chicken stir fry pizza it was amazing something i will definitely order again
Carol Murphy
Mar 7,2026
5/5
We ordered on line and had it delivered. The food arrived timely and was warm. Everything arrived exactly as ordered and was delicious. The boneless wings with everything sauce were as ordered crispy with plenty of blue cheese. I will definitely order from Big Jays again!
Lorie Phillips
Mar 7,2026
4/5
Every time I get take out pizza at Big Jay, I am impressed how polite, friendly and accommodating the staff is. The pizza is good and flavorful. Big Jays realizes that customer service is very important! Good job.
ks killa
Mar 7,2026
5/5
I'm from Queens, NYC and this pizza is as good as my neighborhood pie spot! It's literally the best pizza I've ever had outside of NYC and better than some places in NYC! The lady who helped me place my order was friendly and helpful. I ended up with a small pie which was DELICIOUS!! I couldn't decide between the pizza or a stromboli. I'll go back tomorrow for lunch and get the stromboli. The owner appears to be a big football fan. Numerous jerzees hand on the walls in the restaurant. Outside there is plenty of parking.
Jean Allaire
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Today I decided I wanted a chicken cesar wrap and ordered one from Big Jay's I noticed that they have fried cheese curd and decided to try that too. The wrap was huge! I had trouble finishing 1/2! Flavor was on point too! But the cheese curd with sweet chili dipping sauce stole the show! After eating 1/2 a wrap I couldn't eat too many but they were fantastic! And that dipping sauce was perfect! I have never been unhappy with anything I have had a Big Jays, I think today has to be one of my favorites!

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More in Marcy, New York, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!